Stacked Pickle - 96th Street

Reviews

• Kaitlyn S.

  star star star star star 6 June 2026

  Came here for trivia and a friends birthday. The staff was very nice and even filled up a birthday goblet I had gotten for my friend for her birthday. They do trivia weekly and the host was fun and it was loud enough you could hear everything. They were a little understaffed but told us up front so it wasn't a big deal that drinks took a little bit. Food was okay, fried pickles were great! My burger was okay, nothing special but not awful by any means. I'll def be back for trivia

• Tony J.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 29 May 2026

  Horrible service. Sign states "Please Seat Yourself". Sat at booth table, there were no other customers in the dining area, all were at the bar. Sat there for 3-4 minutes and was never acknowledged by any employee. Needless to say, we left the establishment.
  
  I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone!

• Alicia R.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 18 May 2026

  If i could give negative stars I would. The service I received from the server and bartender were AWFUL!!! We were there to celebrate an event and they ruined the experience.

• Rachael M.

  star star star star_border star_border 15 May 2026

  I was running errands and saw their Tuesday special, fish tacos, on social media and they looked very good. So after my first stop drove a few minutes out of the way to get them for lunch. I tried calling the restaurant as I drove to order carry out but was not successful. Someone picked up and it was silent for 45 seconds. Not getting an answer I just hung up. Lucky for me, the restaurant was not very busy at noon so I was able to order and get my food very quickly. One complaint, there was no one to greet me when I walked in. I decided just to go to the bar and order my lunch. Bartender got my order in and I was out in less than 10 minutes.
  
  The fish taco special comes with 3 soft tacos and caesar salad. Not a huge fan of the caesar dressing, but the lettuce was fresh and crisp and had plenty of buttery croutons. The tacos were good - I was impressed with how large the fish portions were. It was slightly cold however. I'm not sure if it was because of the citrus/mango salsa that comes with it or if the tortillas weren't warmed up, but it didn't taste like it was just made five minutes ago.
  
  This is the second location of Stacked Pickle I've been to and both places the food has been decent. Service can be better in both places. They have really good specials - the fish tacos were $7.50 and was very filling. I'm sure I'll keep coming back as my husband likes the pub/restaurant food and atmosphere.

• Charlotte H.

  star star star star star 13 May 2026

  Made advance reservations for our baseball team and families for Friday night. Hayley was our server and she was amazing!! The tables were ready for us when we walked in (Can I just say how grateful I am for that?!)  She got our drinks and orders in and kept everything moving throughout the night. The guys were happy with all the sports on TV.  And, most importantly - the food was great.  I had the Big Pickle burger - huge, juicy, perfectly cooked!! Also heard the wings, salads and chicken fingers were good. Everyone loved the fries.  Thanks for a great night!